Send Close Add comments: (status displays here)
Got it!  This site "creationpie.org" uses cookies. You consent to this by clicking on "Got it!" or by continuing to use this website.  Note: This appears on each machine/browser from which this site is accessed.
Book: Fabricating Jesus
by RS  admin@creationpie.org : 1024 x 640


1. Book: Fabricating Jesus
This content is being developed.

2. Book: Fabricating Jesus
Book: Fabricating Jesus
The book Fabricating Jesus by Craig Evans presents a lot of interesting research. As with many books about Christian theology and apologetics, there is a lot of hand-waving and not a lot of verifiable logic. Many ideas are based on English translations that often use the Latin meanings of words and not the original Greek meanings of the words. Here, some observations are made. More will be added as interesting issues are discovered.

When reading these notes, please keep in mind the following: Just because someone uses invalid logic, facts, etc., to attempt to prove a point does not mean that the point they are trying to prove is not true.

3. Fabricating Jesus: Alternative trilemma alternatives
Trilemma 1 Book: Fabricating Jesus
In his book Fabricating Jesus, author Craig Evans assumes the sets for "Liar, lunatic or Lord" are mutually exclusive and calls it an excluded middle fallacy. In a logical analysis, one should not jump to that conclusion until further in the general analysis.
He then presents his view (opinion) that "Lord" is not a viable alternative and presents his opinion on other alternatives outside of the domain of "Liar, lunatic or Lord".

Information sign More: Trilemma: liar lunatic or Lord

4. Baptism embarrassment
On page 140, the following is stated under Embarrassment. ... one such event in the life of Jesus was his baptism by John. John summoned Israel to repent and be baptized. In what sense did Jesus need to repent? According to Christian theology, Jesus was sinless, so he did not need to repent. Hence, the story of Jesus baptism is potentially awkward or embarrassing. Surely the early church would not invent a story like this if it had no basis in historical fact. Therefore, even the most server critics concede that the story of Jesus' baptism is authentic.

The questionable logic is that since this story was included, and potentially embarrassing, it proves the authentic nature of what was written. This questionable logic assumes the modern English meaning of repent. Greek had two words that are translated as repent. IIf the author understood the underlying Greek meanings and implications, the embarrassment issue disappears. Why then is this not pointed out?

Information sign More: Think after what you heard and repent

5. Repent summary
Verse routeRomans 11:29 For the gifts and calling of God are without repentance. [kjv]
Verse routeαμεταμελητα γαρ τα χαρισματα και η κλησις του θεου [gnt]
Verse routepaenitentiadonavocatio … [v]

Verse routeMatthew 3:2 And saying, Repent ye: for the kingdom of heaven is at hand. [kjv]
Verse route λεγων μετανοειτε ηγγικεν γαρ η βασιλεια των ουρανων [gnt]
Verse routepaenitentiam … [v]

Paraphrase: Think about it!. The "kingdom of heaven" is near or "at hand". The KJV (King James Version) translates both verses using the Latin word "paenitentia""repentance, penitence, regret".

Information sign More: Think after what you heard and repent

6. Inferred attitude and observed behavior
Attitude and behavior
The ancient Greek word "μετάνοια""afterthought" where the "repent" comes from the GNT (Greek New Testament) (from the Latin).
This word has to do with unobserved attitude and not observed behavior.

The ancient Greek word "μεταμέλεια""change of purpose, regret, repentance" which is the modern idea of the Latin-based "repent".

This word has to do with observed behavior and not inferred attitude.

Both words are used by Jesus in Matthew. If Jesus had intended to use modern meaning from Latin-based word "repent", there was a Greek word to express that idea and it was not used.

Information sign More: Think after what you heard and repent

7. End of page

by RS  admin@creationpie.org : 1024 x 640